Vikings Mailbag: QB Competition, Harrison Smith’s Future, and Free-Agent Plans

After taking a brief hiatus, the Vikings mailbag returns, answering key fan queries as training camp nears in just several weeks. Here, we cover key topics related to team’s prospects in 2018-19 season.

Vikings’ Summer Outlook Still Uncertain

Question: Do you think the Vikings will reach the playoffs this year?

Answer: Yes.

The roster seems capable enough to push for the playoffs; the only major hurdle is the competitive nature of the NFC North division. Historically, there’s usually at least one weaker team in the division, but now that no such “pushover” exists, the fight will be tougher than ever.

If Minnesota can navigate a challenging schedule, finishing with at least a 10-7 record is within reach. This belief stems from last season’s performance when the Vikings went 9-8 despite inconsistent quarterback play. With a more reliable quarterback this year, securing a Wildcard playoff spot looks achievable.

The defense remains championship-caliber, anchored by strong leadership, while the offense will rely heavily on maximizing the talents of the new quarterback. An 11-6 finish with a Wildcard playoff game against a team like Tampa Bay or New Orleans is a reasonable expectation.

Free-Agent Targets for the Vikings

Question: If Minnesota signs any free agents, who will it be?

Answer: Leonard Floyd.

The head coach and Floyd have a history together, including a Super Bowl win, and the team likely needs to add a third pass rusher. There are several strong options available at outside linebacker this offseason, including Floyd as well as other veteran pass rushers. Expect Minnesota to bring in additional edge-rushing help either soon or later in the summer as rosters are trimmed.

Another logical addition would be a guard, as the current backup situation along the offensive line is fragile. The Vikings could be just one injury away from starting a less experienced lineup on the interior. Depth options such as Will Hernandez and James Daniels are potential targets to shore up that position.

Harrison Smith’s Status

Question: Any word on Harrison Smith? Is he coming back?

Answer: We believe so.

Recent insider information suggests that Smith will return, though an official announcement has yet to be made. His strong late-season play last year indicates he still has something to offer, even if his role might be more situational moving forward.

Given the team’s promising outlook and the arrival of a new quarterback, it seems unlikely Smith would want to miss out on a potential playoff run. For now, it is assumed he’ll be back with the Vikings for one final season.

Quarterback Competition at Training Camp

Question: Who will win the quarterback battle at training camp?

Answer: Kyler Murray.

This contest appears straightforward. Since entering the league, Murray has demonstrated stronger production metrics than several other high-profile quarterbacks. He arrives already established as a worthy starter.

At present, J.J. McCarthy still has room to grow and develop into an NFL starter-caliber quarterback. Both players have recently dealt with injuries, so whomever wins may face setbacks during the year that allow the other to come in.

Murray stands out as an experienced leader with arm strength, accuracy and mobility; though McCarthy may still present himself as an option to lead their team. A surprising victory would likely go to Murray alone.